All articles

Adaptogens by stress type: what the data say and what to check first

Adaptogens by stress type: what the data say and what to check first

in pictures and a few words

What it is and why it matters

The “Stress Type” questionnaire sorts complaints into three types. It is a hint for choosing remedies, not a diagnosis.

  • Type 1 — “on edge”: tension, hard to switch off and fall asleep
  • Type 2 — “low energy”: not enough strength from the morning on
  • Type 3 — “immune system”: frequent, lingering colds

Tension and sleep

Ashwagandha is a plant that has been studied in stress. In studies in people it reduced stress, and sleep improved a little.

  • Passionflower is a long-used remedy for mild tension and for sleep
  • If complaints on passionflower last longer than 2 weeks, see a doctor
  • Ashwagandha is not suitable with liver disease or an overactive thyroid

When stress is severe

In people with severe stress and low blood magnesium, magnesium together with vitamin B6 helped more than magnesium alone.

  • In that study, vitamin B6 was given above the safe limit
  • The limit for adults: vitamin B6 — no more than 12 mg a day
  • Magnesium from supplements, water and fortified foods — no more than 250 mg a day

Low energy in the morning

An examination comes first: morning weakness occurs with depression, anemia, a sluggish thyroid and adrenal disease. This type is a reason to get examined, not a reason for licorice.

  • In studies, ginseng reduced fatigue; it has long been used for loss of strength
  • A substance called coenzyme Q10 also reduced fatigue — moderately
  • Rhodiola may help: some studies showed an effect
Weakness in the morningTests and a doctor’s talkThen choose a remedy

Frequent colds

First, look for the cause: a blood count, blood sugar, iron stores and zinc. If infections are severe, need antibiotics several times a year, or are unusual, see an immunologist.

  • Vitamin D slightly reduced the number of people with airway infections
  • Vitamin C — colds half as often in people under heavy physical exertion
  • Zinc may shorten a cold that has already started by about a couple of days

Mind and cycle

Bacopa has been studied under heavy mental workload. In long courses, from 12 weeks, it mainly sped up attention.

  • For premenstrual syndrome, calcium is the best studied
  • Vitex may help with premenstrual syndrome; the course is at least 3 months
  • With an irregular cycle, pregnancy is ruled out first and prolactin is tested

Blood pressure and heart

First, a doctor rules out serious causes of blood pressure swings and palpitations. Hawthorn and motherwort have long been used for nervous heart complaints — after that check.

  • Omega-3 fats help lower blood pressure
  • In people with type 2 diabetes, hawthorn slightly lowered the bottom number
  • Magnesium slightly lowered the top number, at a dose above the limit: only with a doctor

Important. If you faint or have chest pain or shortness of breath — call an ambulance: 112.

How to take it

There is no ready-made schedule: what, how much and for how long is chosen at a consultation after tests. Herbs have maximum courses.

  • Eleuthero — up to 2 months, echinacea — up to 10 days, ginseng — up to 3 months
  • Vitamin D — no more than 4,000 IU (100 µg) a day for adults
  • Name all herbs and supplements to your doctor, not “something for stress”
QuestionnaireTests and consultationChoice and duration

If you take medicines

Do not stop steroid anti-inflammatory medicines on your own. If you take them, or medicines for blood pressure, depression or thinning the blood, remedies are chosen only with a doctor.

  • Bipolar disorder: rhodiola is not suitable; energizing remedies only with a psychiatrist
  • With high blood pressure, swelling or low potassium, licorice is not suitable
  • Before surgery, tell your surgeon and anesthesiologist about all herbs and supplements

Important. If you vomit, feel sudden weakness or faint while on steroids or after stopping them — call 112 and tell the crew about the steroids.

Who should see a doctor first

Weakness together with low blood pressure, darkening of the skin or weight loss is a reason to see an endocrinologist within the next few days. Adaptogens and licorice are not started before that visit.

  • Worsening easy bruising, purple face and purple stretch marks — endocrinologist, urgently
  • Pregnancy, breastfeeding, under 18 — adaptogens and herbs are not used
  • Jaundice, nausea or itching on ashwagandha, kava or skullcap — stop and see a doctor

Important. If right now there is severe weakness, vomiting, abdominal pain, confusion or fainting, this is an emergency: call 112.

In one sentence

For each stress type there are remedies that helped people in studies; first the red flags and tests, then the choice of remedies at a consultation.

Frequently asked questions

In a meta-analysis of 12 randomized controlled trials (RCTs), ashwagandha had a favorable effect on stress scores at 300–600 mg a day, and on sleep it had a small but statistically significant effect. For fatigue, ginseng reduced it across 4 RCTs in a meta-analysis, and coenzyme Q10 moderately, across 13 RCTs. For lowering blood pressure, the optimal omega-3 intake is 2–3 g a day; for PMS, there is good-quality evidence for calcium. What suits you specifically is chosen at a consultation, after tests.

In a meta-analysis of randomized trials (estimate from 37 of them), vitamin D slightly but significantly reduced the proportion of people with a respiratory infection: 61.3% versus 62.3% (Jolliffe 2021). Regular vitamin C at 200 mg a day or more made colds half as frequent in people under heavy physical exertion but did not reduce their incidence in the general population (2013 Cochrane review). When treating a cold, zinc may shorten it by about 2.4 days (Cochrane 2024). Before remedies are chosen, the questionnaire suggests looking for the causes of frequent infections: a complete blood count, glucose, ferritin, zinc.

No: the questionnaire groups complaints; it does not measure hormones. “Adrenal fatigue” is not a diagnosis: no endocrinology society recognizes it, and a systematic review of 58 studies found no substantiation that it is an actual medical condition (Cadegiani, BMC Endocr Disord 2016). In chronic stress, both increased and decreased activity of the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis have been found (Miller, Psychol Bull 2007), so the direction of the shift cannot be guessed from complaints — only tests can answer that.

Morning fatigue occurs in depression and in adrenal insufficiency; when signs of adrenal insufficiency are present, the Endocrine Society (2016) advises testing for it. Under the HMPC monograph (the EMA Committee on Herbal Medicinal Products), licorice is indicated only for dyspepsia and cough; in a meta-analysis, at 100 mg or more of glycyrrhizic acid a day systolic blood pressure was 5.45 mm Hg higher. Ginseng in bipolar disorder — only as agreed with a psychiatrist: cases of mania have been described. If right now there is vomiting, severe weakness, abdominal pain or fainting — call 112.

Its safety has not been established, and it is unknown who is sensitive. In a case series, liver injury appeared after 2–12 weeks (Björnsson 2020); thyrotoxicosis has been described, and in a randomized trial in subclinical hypothyroidism the extract raised thyroxine (T4) (Sharma 2018). The Dutch RIVM (2024) advises, as a precaution, not to use it, particularly in pregnancy; Germany’s BfR advises that especially children, pregnant and breastfeeding women and people with liver disease should not take it. France’s ANSES advises abstaining in thyroid, liver and heart disease.

The HMPC monographs (the EMA Committee on Herbal Medicinal Products) on rhodiola, ginseng, eleuthero, valerian and passionflower: safety during pregnancy and lactation has not been established, and use is not recommended — because of a lack of data, not proven harm. For licorice the monograph is stricter: reproductive toxicity has been shown in animals. In pregnancy, when planning a pregnancy and while breastfeeding, the questionnaire does not offer adaptogens, herbs, the hormone DHEA or 5-hydroxytryptophan; vitamins and minerals — as agreed with your doctor.

The set is determined by a doctor; the questionnaire only reminds you what to rule out first. For Type 2 · “low energy” — morning cortisol together with ACTH (the pituitary hormone), sodium and potassium, TSH and free T4 (thyroid markers), a complete blood count, ferritin with C-reactive protein, vitamin B12. Plus two questions about mood (PHQ-2). For Type 1 · “on edge” — TSH and free T4; for Type 3 · “immune system” — a complete blood count with differential, glucose, ferritin, zinc; vitamin D if indicated.

Tell your surgeon and anesthesiologist everything you take, including glucocorticoids in any form. A review in JAMA (Ang-Lee 2001) lists herbs that complicate the perioperative period: bleeding (garlic, ginkgo, ginseng), hypoglycemia (ginseng), potentiation of sedation (kava, valerian). The HMPC monograph (the EMA Committee on Herbal Medicinal Products) on ginkgo advises stopping it 3–4 days before surgery; rauwolfia (reserpine) must not be stopped on your own — the timing is set by the doctor who prescribed it.

According to the Endocrine Society (2008), glucocorticoid use is ruled out first. Testing is done when several progressive features are present (easy bruising, a flushed reddish face, weakness of the thigh and shoulder muscles, reddish-purple stretch marks wider than 1 cm), when features are unusual for one’s age, or when an adrenal mass is found incidentally; testing everyone else is not advised. The test is 24-hour urinary free cortisol (at least 2 collections), late-night salivary cortisol (twice) or a dexamethasone test; if abnormal — an endocrinologist and a second test.

Share
Follow on TelegramGet new articles, research updates and practical health tips
Читать на русскомЧитати українською

This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician before making health decisions. Full disclaimer

Ready to Take Action?

A consultation starts where the article ends: your history, your labs, a plan for your case.

Book consultationAsk a question