All articles

Knuckle Cracking and Arthritis: What Studies Show

What studies showed about cracking and arthritis

Where the sound comes from

The authors of the studies think a gas cavity appears in the joint.

  • the sound is born when the joint is stretched
  • the mechanism remains a matter of debate
  • it cannot be said for certain yet

What was studied

They compared those who crack their knuckles with those who do not.

  • surveys
  • examination by doctors
  • ultrasound and MRI

Cracking and osteoarthritis

People with hand osteoarthritis did not crack more often than the rest.

  • osteoarthritis: wear of cartilage in a joint
  • no link with cracking was found
  • the conclusions are about association, not cause

What is linked to osteoarthritis

Age and cases in the family were linked to osteoarthritis.

  • age matters
  • family history too
  • cracking did not make this list

How many years of cracking

Neither the number of years of cracking nor "crack-years" were linked to osteoarthritis.

  • years of cracking: no link
  • crack-years: no link

Mobility

Right after cracking, the finger bends and straightens slightly further.

  • the increase is small
  • the authors call the significance unclear
  • cracking cannot be considered beneficial

Grip strength

On examination, grip strength did not differ between crackers and non-crackers.

  • measured with a dynamometer
  • in healthy adults
  • with no complaints about the hands

Swelling

Doctors who did not know who cracked found no swelling.

  • in no one in the group
  • including right after cracking

What was said earlier

An old study reported swelling and weak grip, but its abstract gives no figures.

  • in young adults in 2017 this was not found
  • one doctor's letter about himself is not considered evidence

Age of participants

The studies included people of different ages.

  • survey: 215 people aged 50–89
  • examination: 40 adults, average age 33–34
  • there are no long-term follow-up studies yet

What to do

In these studies, crackers had neither more osteoarthritis, nor swelling, nor weak grip.

  • do not pull a joint through pain
  • very forceful cracking has sometimes been described as a cause of injuries

When to see a doctor

Pain and swelling matter more than any cracking.

  • pain or redness of a joint
  • swelling or difficulty bending a finger
  • cracking after an injury

Frequently asked questions

Studies in people found no link between cracking and hand osteoarthritis: 18.0% of people with osteoarthritis (135 people) and 23.2% without it (80 people) cracked their knuckles. This is an observation, not a study that followed people many years ahead.

The authors of the studies think a gas cavity forms in the joint: on MRI in 1 man (10 joints) it appeared with every crack. The mechanism remains a matter of debate.

In an examination of 40 adults, grip strength did not differ between crackers and non-crackers (right hand 83.8 vs 77.9 lb, that is about 38.0 and 35.3 kg). A 1990 study, by its abstract, reported weak grip, but in 2017 in young adults, doctors who did not know who cracked saw no difference.

In 40 adults, 62 of 400 joints cracked; right after cracking, passive range of motion in them rose from 137.8° to 145.6°. The authors call the clinical significance unclear, so cracking cannot be considered beneficial.

If there is pain, swelling, redness, the fingers do not bend well, or the cracking started after an injury.

Share
Follow on TelegramGet new articles, research updates and practical health tips
Читать на русскомЧитати українською

This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician before making health decisions. Full disclaimer

Ready to Take Action?

A consultation starts where the article ends: your history, your labs, a plan for your case.

Book consultationAsk a question