All articles

Personalized Nutraceuticals: Why "One Vitamin for Everyone" Doesn't Work

Personalized Nutraceuticals: Why "One Vitamin for Everyone" Doesn't Work

in pictures and a few words

What it is and why it matters

These are supplements put together for a specific person: based on their tests, genes and the medicines they take.

  • An ordinary multivitamin has the same forms and doses for everyone
  • People respond very differently to the same dose of vitamin D
  • Many supplements bring no noticeable benefit — the article argues this is because of the “one size fits all” approach

Genes hint at the form and dose

In many people, because of gene variants, one of the enzymes works more weakly. Then it matters in what form and dose to take vitamins.

  • A weak folate enzyme — you need the ready-made form, methylfolate, not folic acid
  • A special vitamin D gene variant — a higher-than-usual dose may be needed; it is adjusted by a blood test
  • Another variant: large doses of active B vitamins may cause anxiety and insomnia

Tests that see more

Ordinary blood tests find only obvious shortages. There are tests that show your stores more precisely.

  • Magnesium inside red blood cells: only a small share of it is in the liquid part of blood
  • A urine test for special acids hints at a shortage of vitamins B12 and B6
  • Homocysteine is an overall marker: it rises when the folate enzyme is weaker
A precise testHidden shortage showsForm and dose chosen

The form of a substance matters

The same substance in different forms can be absorbed several times better or worse. What matters is not only “what”, but also “in what form”.

  • Magnesium as glycinate is absorbed much better than as oxide
  • Zinc from oxide is absorbed less well than from other forms
  • Special forms of curcumin are absorbed many times better than the ordinary one

Medicines take their toll

Some medicines get in the way of absorbing or making substances the body needs. This is worth keeping in mind when choosing supplements.

  • Statins lower the body’s production of coenzyme Q10 — the article advises adding 100–200 mg a day
  • Metformin makes vitamin B12 harder to absorb — check B12 every 6 months
  • Omeprazole, pantoprazole: magnesium, calcium, iron and B12 are absorbed less well

The thyroid pill

Calcium, iron and coffee interfere with absorbing thyroid hormone tablets — levothyroxine.

  • Take the tablet on an empty stomach, 60 minutes before food and coffee
  • Calcium and iron — no closer than 4 hours to the tablet
Tablet on empty stomachWait 60 minutesFood and coffee

How a personal formula is built

First, they look at the person’s tests, genes and the medicines they take. Then a pharmacy makes capsules with the right forms and doses.

  • A genetic test is not required, but the article strongly recommends it
  • Even without genes, precise tests noticeably improve the choice
  • The formula is reviewed every 3–6 months, and sooner if treatment changes
Tests and medicinesYour own capsule formulaCheck in 3–6 months

Clean raw materials

A personal capsule is only as good as its raw materials are clean. Some of the Ayurvedic supplements tested contained lead, mercury and arsenic.

  • Ask for a test certificate for each batch: content, heavy metals, microbes
  • Look for independent quality-testing marks on the package
  • Curcumin, omega-3 and coenzyme Q10 spoil in light and above 25 °C — dark capsules are needed

Who should see a doctor first

Before starting any supplement plan, you need to consult a specialist. Especially if you take medicines regularly.

  • Statins, metformin, omeprazole or pantoprazole — choose supplements together with your doctor
  • Thyroid tablets — with your doctor, space them apart in time from calcium, iron and coffee
  • Anxiety and insomnia from active B vitamins — the dose is chosen by a doctor

Important. The article is for reference and is not a guide to self-treatment: start any plan only after consulting a specialist.

In one sentence

Supplements work better when they are chosen for your tests, genes and medicines — in the right form, from clean raw materials and together with your doctor.

Frequently asked questions

According to a systematic review in JAMA Internal Medicine (2020), up to 50% of supplements provide no measurable health benefit. The reason is not that nutrients are useless but the one-size-fits-all approach: universal formulas ignore genetic polymorphisms, gastrointestinal status, drug interactions, and current nutritional status. For example, in a study in Nature Medicine (2023), the metabolic response to identical doses of vitamin D varied 6-fold between individuals.

Up to 40% of the population carry at least one polymorphism of the MTHFR gene (C677T, A1298C), which reduces the activity of the enzyme methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase by 30–70%. This impairs methylation and raises homocysteine. For this reason, carriers are better served by methylfolate (5-methyltetrahydrofolate, 5-MTHF) rather than ordinary folic acid.

The bioavailability of the same substance depends strongly on its form. Magnesium is absorbed at about 4% from oxide and up to 80% from glycinate; zinc is absorbed at about 61% from citrate and gluconate versus about 50% from oxide (Journal of Nutrition, 2014). Curcumin has a bioavailability of 2–3% in its standard form, 29 times higher in phytosomal form, and 185 times higher in micellar form.

Metformin reduces vitamin B12 absorption by about 30%, so B12 is monitored every 6 months. Statins suppress the synthesis of coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10), while proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) such as omeprazole reduce the absorption of magnesium, calcium, iron, and B12. Calcium, iron, and coffee reduce levothyroxine absorption: the tablet is taken on an empty stomach 60 minutes before food and coffee, and calcium and iron no closer than 4 hours to it.

Genetic testing is not mandatory, but it is recommended. Even without it, functional tests noticeably improve prescribing accuracy: urinary organic acids (OAT), red blood cell (RBC) minerals, and homocysteine. The formula is reviewed every 3–6 months based on follow-up laboratory results.

Share
Follow on TelegramGet new articles, research updates and practical health tips
Читать на русскомЧитати українською

This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician before making health decisions. Full disclaimer

Ready to Take Action?

A consultation starts where the article ends: your history, your labs, a plan for your case.

Book consultationAsk a question